What are the advantages and disadvantages of public schooling over homeschooling?

Answer 1

I posted this question, as I am trying to figure out whether to send my kids back to school for 3rd & 4th grade (they've been homeschooled for thelast two years). This is what I've come up with so far: Advantages: 1. Enrichment built into school day - no $100 monthly here and there for each class in PE, art, piano, IEW writing, etc... 2. More opportunities for social interaction and group projects - I am in a crowded suburban area, but there seems to be a shortage of girls my daughter's age. My son is very shy, and because there isn't repeated daily interaction with kids, he just isn't connecting well enough with kids he might see even weekly or several times a month. Of course, there is no guarantee they'll have more friends in school, but that is a distinct possibility. 3. The extras the public schools do, variety show, science fair, afterschool activities, field days, etc... 4. Practice responding to other authority figures, having another adult interested in their growth and development (I realize this is a bit idealistic, but there ARE good, dedicated teachers out there) 5. Regular practice in self-discipline, following rules and shouldering responsibilities in a highly structured environment 6. Breadth of public school instruction - lots of breadth, perhaps not so much depth, but they'd get exposed to lots of subject matter 7. Give my kids a greater appreciation for the benefits and flexibility of homeschooling 8. Less time in the car Disadvantages: 1. Not much 1-1 instruction or tailored instruction 2. Allergic reactions (Allergies to milk, egg, nuts, and latex) 3. Potential for bullying, esp. shy son 4. Busy work and possibly excessive homework load 5. Potential for negative socialization (cheating, lying, being mean, etc...) 6. Potential for bad/mean teachers 7. Kids might be unhappy 8. Dealing with constant fundraisers and appreciation days etc...