0
What was one crucial dispute that Leon Trotsky had with the Mensheviks in 1920?
Wiki User
∙ 9y ago
During the period of War Communism in the new Soviet Union, Leon Trotsky used the forum of the Third Congress of Trade Unions to justify the military tactics used against industrial workers. He attacked the Menshevik idea that such force and compulsion was counter productive and clearly an anti labor position by the Communists. Trotsky claimed that to move forward with the "revolution" that workers who did not cooperate would face military "justice". The Mensheviks were appalled at this.
Wiki User
∙ 9y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
What was a basic belief of Leon Trotsky concerning the relationship of trade unions and the Soviet government?
As early as 1920, Leon Trotsky stood firm on his belief that trade unions and the Soviet government could have conflicting interests. With that being the case as far as Trotsky was concerned, the trade unions needed to be educated on this crucial point. Trotsky saw the problems that workers were having with the Soviet government and to help solve them, he proposed a "shake up" so to speak of unions and union members who disagreed with Trotsky. Here we see how the early beliefs of Trotsky were changed once he and the Bolsheviks came into power. Early on in his career, he pushed for the protection of the workers' trade unions. Later, once in power he reversed his position. In exile, he reverted to his original idea about government suppression of the workers.
What leader did Leon trotsky use his pen to oppose?
In the 1920's, Leon Trotsky opposed the bureaucracy and policies of Josef Stalin. As a result, he was removed from power in 192,7 and deported from the Soviet Union in 1929. He found asylum in Mexico and continued his opposition to the Stalinist government. He and most of his family were killed on Stalin's orders.
How were Leon Trotsky and Vladimir Lenin linked?
Vladimir Lenin and Leon Trotsky were both editors of the Iskra in Russian 1902. Lenin and Trotsky were also both Russian revolutionaries, even though they did not see eye to all on all things related to this. However, in 1904 the men reconciled their differences.
Who is the Soviet leader who founded the Red Army?
When Leon Trotsky and Vladamir Lenin returned from exile in 1917, they set out to overthrow Russia's Provisional government. This was accomplished with death and violence. In addition to Trotsky's brilliant skills as a Bolshevik propagandist he was also a great organizer. He used this skill to organize the Bolshevik's army. Trotsky was the War Minister and head of the Red Army.The Bolshevik revolution faced opposition and Trotsky's Red Army had to defeat the Russian nobles' White army. Also, another foe to the Bolsheviks were troops organized outside of Russia. This included the opposition forces from the WW 1 Allies who felt betrayed when Lenin ended Russia's role in the World War. Troops from Poland also invaded Russia.From 1917 to 1920 Trotsky's Red Army defeated all of the foes of the Bolsheviks. Credit for this was given to Trotsky's leadership and skills in defeating counter revolutionary forces.
Who did Lenin want to replace Stalin?
He was adverse to Stalin taking over, so he probably wanted Trotsky to come to power.
Who was the civil war fought in russia between in 1918 to 1920?
Bolsheviks and mensheviks
Who participated in civil war fought in Russia from 1918 -1920?
Bolsheviks and Mensheviks
Who participated in civil war fought in Russia from 1918 1920?
Bolsheviks and Mensheviks
Who participated in the civil war fought in Russia from 1918 to 1920?
Bolsheviks and mensheviks
Who was the civil war fought in Russia from 1918 to 1920 between?
The Reds and the Whites. The reds were the revolutionaries pro-communists, the whites were the supporters of the previous regime Tzarism.
What was a basic belief of Leon Trotsky concerning the relationship of trade unions and the Soviet government?
As early as 1920, Leon Trotsky stood firm on his belief that trade unions and the Soviet government could have conflicting interests. With that being the case as far as Trotsky was concerned, the trade unions needed to be educated on this crucial point. Trotsky saw the problems that workers were having with the Soviet government and to help solve them, he proposed a "shake up" so to speak of unions and union members who disagreed with Trotsky. Here we see how the early beliefs of Trotsky were changed once he and the Bolsheviks came into power. Early on in his career, he pushed for the protection of the workers' trade unions. Later, once in power he reversed his position. In exile, he reverted to his original idea about government suppression of the workers.
When did soccer first begin in the U.S.?
between 1900 and 1920. it is an on-going dispute.
Who participated in the civil war fought in Russia from 1918 1920?
The Reds and the Whites. The reds were the revolutionaries pro-communists, the whites were the supporters of the previous regime Tzarism.
Why did trotsky leave Russia?
Leon Trotsky was part of the Bolshevic party during the early years of the USSR. After Lenin (the previous leader of the USSR) died in the 1920's, Trotsky and Joseph Stalin both fought for the power of ruling the USSR. Stalin won, and then exiled Trotsky, afraid that he might organize a military coup to overthrow Stalin.
What role did Leon Trotsky play in the 1920's in the USSR?
Bolshevik Leon Trotsky found himself in deep trouble by the unexpected death of Vladimir Lenin. In the years between 1923 and 1928, Trotsky was both a political leader and intellectual guide of the left opposition groups. The left wing of the Soviet communist party was against the despotism of Stalin.Trotsky's skill at conveying the true meaning of Marxism became a threat to Stalin. Trotsky's proven abilities as an active communist, a key part of the 1917 revolution, was feared by Stalin and his supporters.
What leader did Leon trotsky use his pen to oppose?
In the 1920's, Leon Trotsky opposed the bureaucracy and policies of Josef Stalin. As a result, he was removed from power in 192,7 and deported from the Soviet Union in 1929. He found asylum in Mexico and continued his opposition to the Stalinist government. He and most of his family were killed on Stalin's orders.
What progressive role did Leon Trotsky play in Soviet politics in the middle of the 1920's?
It can be safely said that between 1923 to 1928, Trotsky did his best to stick to the ideals of the October 1917 revolution. He became both the political leader and intellectual guide of the left opposition groups that attacked the growing oppression of the Stalin regime.
