0
Who argued that the Constitution did not specifically grant Congress the power to establish a national bank?
Wiki User
∙ 7y ago
Wiki User
∙ 10y agoHamilton
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Why did Alexander Hamilton argue that the Constitution gave the US government the power to create a national bank?
The Constitution gives Congress power to do useful things. This does not constitute a dangerous interpretation of the Constitution. Powers not specifically given in the Constitution can be implied.
Jefferson and Hamilton differed on the question of whether or not Congress could do what?
They disagreed on practically everything but their esteem for George Washington. Specifically, however, their greatest and most significant difference on a power of Congress was whether Congress could establish a national bank (the "First Bank of the United States"). Hamilton argued that because Article I, section 9 of the Constitution did not specifically prohibit Congress from creating a national bank, then Congress was empowered to do so under Article I, section 8, clause 18 (the "implied powers clause," "necessary and proper clause," or "elastic clause"). Jefferson, who took a more limited view of Federal power, argued that because Article I, section 8 did not specify Congress could create a national bank, then it could not. Jefferson believed that only specified powers (such as power to tax, to maintain an army, to punish counterfeiters, etc.) could be exercised by Congress.
Who wrote the Constitution for China?
the National People's Congress and its standing committee in china.
When did the national assembly complete the draft of the Constitution?
The "national assembly " didn't write the constitution, but congress wrote it from May 1778 to September 1778. The United States has never had a National Assembly.
What part of the constitution does Andrew Hamilton use for his argument for national bank?
According to The supreme Court in McCulloch v. Maryland (1819) said that Article I, Section 8. The "Necessary and Proper" Clause gave Congress the power to establish a national bank.
What do we call the powers of Congress that are specifically listed in the constitution?
Delegated powers of the National Gov. that are spelled out in the Constitution are called expressed powers, aka "enumerated powers"
Why did Alexander Hamilton argue that the Constitution gave the US government the power to create a national bank?
The Constitution gives Congress power to do useful things. This does not constitute a dangerous interpretation of the Constitution. Powers not specifically given in the Constitution can be implied.
Does the national government establish post offices?
It’s true that Article 1, Section 8 says: [The Congress shall have the power] to establish Post Offices and Post Roads. Thus, the Constitution allows the government to get involved in postal services, but that doesn’t mean that it has to.
Can congress establish a national bank?
Yes, anything "necessary and proper" can be performed by Congress. Don't believe me? Check the "Necessary and Proper Clause" (Article 1, Section 8, Clause 18 of the Constitution).
In which amendment did congress lack control over the national treasury?
Congress did not lack control over the national treasury in any specific amendment. The power to control the national treasury is granted to Congress by the U.S. Constitution, specifically in Article I, Section 8, Clause 1. Congress has the authority to levy taxes, borrow money, and allocate funds for government expenses.
An enumerated power is given to?
An enumerated power is a power of congress that is specifically named in the constitution and given to the national government. They allow Congress to exercise powers that the Constitution grants ans long as they have no restrictions in the Bill of Rights and other protections of the Constitution. The tenth amendment states: "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."
Proposals for an amendment to the constitution can be made Congress or by?
a National Convetion
An amendment to the constitution can be proposed by?
congress or a national convention two-thirds vote of congress
Jefferson and Hamilton differed on the question of whether or not Congress could do what?
They disagreed on practically everything but their esteem for George Washington. Specifically, however, their greatest and most significant difference on a power of Congress was whether Congress could establish a national bank (the "First Bank of the United States"). Hamilton argued that because Article I, section 9 of the Constitution did not specifically prohibit Congress from creating a national bank, then Congress was empowered to do so under Article I, section 8, clause 18 (the "implied powers clause," "necessary and proper clause," or "elastic clause"). Jefferson, who took a more limited view of Federal power, argued that because Article I, section 8 did not specify Congress could create a national bank, then it could not. Jefferson believed that only specified powers (such as power to tax, to maintain an army, to punish counterfeiters, etc.) could be exercised by Congress.
Did Thomas Jefferson favor the creation of a national bank?
He didn't because he believed in strict construction of he constitution, which led him to believe that anything that is not written clearly in the constitution should not be done. Thus he opposed the creation of the bank because the constitution did not specifically grant power to Congress to create one. Alexander Hamilton favor the bank, because he believed in lose construction of the Constitution, and according to the "Elastic clause", the congress can do whatever that is for the good of the people. Thus Hamilton was for the creation of the national bank.
Where did congress establish the national capital in 1791?
Philly (Philadelphia)
What was the national constitution created by the thirteen member committee appointment by the Second Continental Congress?
Nataional constitution : The Law
