Best Answer

Both actions are illegal duplication of the recording. The reason rightsholders get more upset with downloading than with recording off the radio is that the file resulting from a download is much easier to further copy and distribute.

It must not be illegal. It must simply be free. I challenge anyone to defy me to why not! Legalities Regarding Downloading Music There are several reasons why recording from the radio is more acceptable than internet file sharing, but it basically boils down to this.

Radio stations pay fees to the appropriate companies for the license to play songs for the public. These fees are to ensure that artists and writers are paid the royalties due them.

Filesharing software providers like Limewire, iMesh, Kazaa, etc. do not pay these fees though some of them charge users a fee to use their software. Any fee that may be charged by these companies is simply a usage or membership fee. Therefore, artists are not receiving their royalties.

Then there is the fact that recording from the radio does not usually allow someone to copy entire albums simply due to the fact that you don't usually find radio stations broadcasting entire albums - with the exception of the occasional radio show.

And your average radio station has a limited broadcasting range. (I don't know anything about Internet Radio so I won't comment on this form of media.)

The Internet allows people to upload single songs or entire albums and make them available to millions upon millions of computer users all over the world - none of whom will be paying for the music thus depriving the creators of the music of their hard earned money. And creating and/or performing music is hard work. If it were easy everyone would be Pop or Rock stars.

If Limewire or Kazaa paid the appropriate fees they could not afford to allow users to share files freely or for their tiny usage fees. So instead they provide the perfectly legal software, and their members/users commit the crime by stealing music and other protected intellectual property!

So then, it is legal for someone to download a song he/she just heard on the radio because he/she has just been subject to the advertisers, who paid the radio station, who paid the people who copyrighted the music.

User Avatar

Wiki User

โˆ™ 2015-09-22 17:19:04
This answer is:
User Avatar
Study guides

Intellectual Property

21 cards

How do you make homework fun

What is intellectual property and four example of intellectual property

Why do authors put the heading in bold print

What is the main purpose of a web crawler program

See all cards

How do you make homework fun

What is intellectual property and four example of intellectual property

What is the code HTML for

Why do authors put the heading in bold print

See all cards

How do you make homework fun

What is the coding language used to create webpages called

What is intellectual property and four example of intellectual property

What type of password is the strongest

See all cards

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Why is downloading music from the Internet illegal when recording from radio is legal since both originate from copyrighted material?
Write your answer...
Related questions

Cons and pros of downloading copyrighted music from the internet?

there are no cons downloading is cool because i believe in free software rights

What are the consequences of illegally downloading copyrighted music from LimeWire?

At WikiAnswers, we do not support downloading copyrighted materials from the internet. This includes but it not limited to Music and Movies. ^good god you moron, he's asking about the "consequences", not your "opinion" on the matter. "we do not support downloading shite". what a twerp.

Will it cost money to download bit torrents?

No, downloading a torrent is free, but really, when you download something off the Internet, it uses your Internet downloads. So when you use those downloads it is basically using up the downloads you pay your Internet company for. So the answer is logically yes but is not allot. Downloading torrents is possibly illegal and could be hazardous to your computer. Downloading a torrent of copyrighted material could land you in legal trouble.

Is realplayer free?

Yes. Download it here and use the Downloading & Recording Manager to download any video off the Internet (Youtube, etc.):

What are the restrictions and limitations of downloading music from the Internet?

There is some material that's free to download, usually for promotional purposes. But most is copyrighted material that the artist really would have liked to be payed for, downloading that stuff w/o paying is illegal.

What is legal to download from the internet?

If it's copyrighted material, it is illegal to download without paying for it (Amazon, iTunes, etc). However, if it is protected under Creative Commons, then there should be no issue in downloading that material.

Illegal downloading from the internet is no different to theft?

Illegal downloading from the internet is no different to theft?

What are the advantages and disadvantages of downloading films from the internet?

To begin, downloading copyrighted movies from the Internet is illegal. Advantages are the convenience and the fact that you don't have to pay anything. Disadvantages are that you don't support the film makers and that you won't get as much features as a DVD would give you, such as extras. Also, downloading any file from the Internet (more frequently in this kind than regular software) offers risk of virus. Aim to safe websites with licensed downloads, that doesn't inflict the law.

Where is the good internet for kumon answer keys?

cant theyre copyrighted

What do you call downloading a file on the internet?

You just answered it yourself - the action of retrieving a copy of data from the Internet is called "downloading".

How do you get your movies from iTunes to finish downloading when the internet cut out in the middle of it downloading?

i was downloading corel draw x3, and internet cutted down in the middel, how can i start my donload from when it was cutted down

Why should one be careful of downloading files from the internet?

Downloading files from the internet can be very harmful to one's computer. One should be careful downloading files from the internet because some downloads contain malicious software and viruses.

How can you adjust internet download speed?

USE Internet Download Manager For downloading files\ AND Vuze for downloading torrents

What standard permits uploading and downloading of files on internet?


Where you get Internet d?

were downloading it...............

How do you unblock downloading Google Chrome on internet explorer?

to internet

How the Internet originate?

the internet originated from...

What can you legally download off of the internet?

Anything which is copyrighted.

Is downloading legal?

It depends on what you are downloading. Much of the information on the internet is free and legal to download.

Will downloading Mozilla affect internet explorer?

No, downloading Firefox shouldn't affext IE

How can you burn the songs from internet radio?

Its possible by downloading a program called Audacity which recognises the audio source and can then record it in real-time. Or go to and check out the recording tools.

Where does illegal downloading occur?


What is music downloading?

Music downloading is reading sound wave files off the internet and sending them to your computer. If you listen to them on the internet you are already downloading them but you cannot save them onto your hard-drive unless you do a full download.

Is content on the web copyrighted?

Everything that is written down or created is copyrighted. It does not matter what media is used to display it. Everything on the internet is copyrighted, whether the poster reserves the rights or decides to share them openly.

How do you get a Gmail picture off of the internet?

You can get a picture from Gmail by downloading it. The down arrow is the sign of downloading. You can get a picture of Internet by Right clicking and save picture as.