0
What two major debates emerged among the delegates in the constitutional convention met in philadelphia in may of 1787?
Wiki User
∙ 14y ago
Representation and Slavery.
- Representation-should the number of legislators be equal for all states or should the larger states have more representatives?
- Slavery-should the number of slaves in a state be used to compute its representation?
New Jersey plan called for equal voting power for each state, because it is a small locked state which cannot expand.
Virginia plan called for voting power based on population as it is the most populous state at the time.
These lead to the Connecticut Compromise:
- The upper house (Senate) would have equal representation and be elected by the lower house
- The lower house (House of Representatives) would be subject to proportional representation
- The 2871:Three-Fifths Compromise]: For purposes of determining the number of representatives in the House, every five slaves would be counted as three. (This did not confer the vote on slaves; it was simply a formula for determining representation in the House of Representatives.) Final wording in the Constitution referred to "all other persons" and the words slave and slaverydo not appear; this same population computation would also be used for determining taxation.
- All proposed legislation having to do with raising money would originate in the House of Representatives.
Slavery- Slavery was an touchy issue at the time, after much debate this was agreed upon, though often not followed:
The North West Ordinance banned slavery in the newly carved out North west territory.
Slaves count as 3/5 of a man for purposes of counting population for representation.
Wiki User
∙ 14y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
What one of the major debates at the constitutional convention was between delegates who wanted a strong federal government and others who favored?
Leaving more power with the states
Who was called the Sage of the Constitutional Convention?
The 81-year-old Benjamin Franklin was literally and figuratively the elder statesman of the Constitutional Convention. He seldom engaged in debates, but rather acted as host, calmed passions, proposed compromises, and urged the delegates to "doubt a little of his own infallibility" and sign the final document.
Why did the delegates decide to keep the debates a secret from public?
The delegates met in secret mostly because of the farmers.
What significance of the Virginia Plan during debates over the formation of an American constitutional government.?
Identify the significance of the Virginia Plan during debates over the formation of an American constitutional government.
What domestic and international concerns prompted the Constitutional Convention of 1787 how were these addressed by the debates of the framers?
During the American Founding, the Constitutional Convention of 1787 was prompted by various domestic and international concerns: internal challenges such as raising revenue had recently (and again) arisen; the ever-present threat of a renewal of hostilities with Great Britain or other European powers was just one international concern. These concerns were generally met through the Convention's writing of the United States Constitution, which brought into existence a much powerful federal government than that conceived by the Articles of Confederation.
What one of the major debates at the constitutional convention was between delegates who wanted a strong federal government and others who favored?
Leaving more power with the states
Why did the final paragraph of the constitution state done in the convention by the unanimous consent of the states present?
The debates and compromises that went into creating the U.S. Constitution were done at a constitutional convention to which Rhode Island refused to send delegates.
Why did the final paragraph of the Constitution state done in convention by the unanimous consent of the state's present?
The debates and compromises that went into creating the U.S. Constitution were done at a constitutional convention to which Rhode Island refused to send delegates.
Why did the final paragraph of the Constitution state done in convention by the unanimous consent of the state present ..?
The debates and compromises that went into creating the U.S. Constitution were done at a constitutional convention to which Rhode Island refused to send delegates.
Why did the final paragraph of the constitution state done in convention by the unanimous consent of the states present..?
The debates and compromises that went into creating the U.S. Constitution were done at a constitutional convention to which Rhode Island refused to send delegates.
Why did the final paragraph of the constitution state done in convention by the unanimous consent of the states present...?
The debates and compromises that went into creating the U.S. Constitution were done at a constitutional convention to which Rhode Island refused to send delegates.
Why did the final paragraph of the Constitution state and ldquoDone in Convention by the Unanimous Consent of the States present?
The debates and compromises that went into creating the U.S. Constitution were done at a constitutional convention to which Rhode Island refused to send delegates.
Who kept the record of the debates at the constitutional convention?
James Maddison
Who kept the records of the debates at the Constitutional convention?
James Maddison
Kept the only existing written record of the debates at the Constitutional Convention?
The written record of the debates that occurred at the Constitutional Convention were kept by James Madison. Madison served as the 4th U.S. President.
Who was called the Sage of the Constitutional Convention?
The 81-year-old Benjamin Franklin was literally and figuratively the elder statesman of the Constitutional Convention. He seldom engaged in debates, but rather acted as host, calmed passions, proposed compromises, and urged the delegates to "doubt a little of his own infallibility" and sign the final document.
Why did the delegates close the windows of the Pennsylvania State House?
If you're talking about the 1787 Philadelphia Convention, they nailed the windows shut to prevent even idle passers-by from overhearing the debates and discussions among the delegates. They were afraid that eavesdroppers would spread rumors about their meeting.
