answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

They were both warriors and fought each other, so death was a natural outcome. Whether the was was justified is another matter. The Greeks were looting western Asia Minor and Troy was one of the targets. Work out what was 'justified' in that.

User Avatar

Wiki User

6y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Is Achilles act of killing Hector justifiable?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about Movies & Television

How does Achilles finally kill Hector?

There was a duel between Hector and Achilles , and Achilles was successful in killing Hector late in the day. it wasnt really a duel, it was an unfair fight, athene helped Achilles overcome hector. Achilles was also wearing god's amour and was fed on ambrosia, Achilles had refused to eat and both Odysseus and Zeus realised that a starved Achilles would be no match for a well fed hector. Achilles killed hector by thrusting his spear into his neck, the only vulnerable spot on hector's body when he was wearing Achilles' armour. both heroes exchanged spear throws, Achilles missed but athene returned his spear, hector did not miss and hit Achilles' shield, however he was tricked by athene who disguised herself as hector's brother deiphoubus holdind another spear for him and then abandoned him. hector then charges Achilles, knowing he is going to die, with his sword and he is likened to a high flying eagle, noble and strong swooping down upon Achilles who is likened to a timid hare. Achilles with athene's help slays his enemy and then proceeds to maltreat hector, this act was deemed disgusting and wrong in homeric times and still today. Zeus grows enfuriated by this as hector was his favourite mortal, aswell as Apollo's and perhaps even ares. Achilles is not the true hero of the iliad and in my view is not even a hero at all. homer intends us to feel great pathos, sympathy, for hector the greatest hero for so many more reasons than just a talented warrior. he is the most noble and brave character in Homer's Iliad.


What unforgivable act does Achilles commit at the end of The Iliad?

Achilles gets very angry at Hector for killing Patroclus his brother so he decides to get back at him. So he kills Hector, and drags his precious body around on the back of his chariot, while the whole town was watching in astonishment. Then he took him, so that he could not have his proper burial. Achilles was supposed to leave his body on the battlefield, but he was so enraged.


Why is Achilles the protagonist and why is he flawed?

Achilles flaws are that he is driven by anger and revenge. A true hero's characteristics are goodness and honor. Achilles did not possess either and he desecrated Hector's body which is considered deplorable.


What does achillies do with hectors body?

Achilles drags Hector's body to show off that he killed him, as an act of revenge and to make himself feel better about the death of Patroclus, but the God's restored Hector's body, which infuriated Achilles even more. He later on realizes that revenge and violence is not the answer.


What does Laertes accuse Claudius of?

Laertes accuses Claudius of killing his father Polonius in Act IV, Scene V.

Related questions

What is the meaning of the statement Achilles absent was Achilles still?

it means that although Achilles is not present, his presence is still felt through his influence on those who are. Achilles makes this statement to Hector after mortally wounding him to avenge his friend, Patroclus, whom Hector had killed while Patroclus wore Achilles armor. Achilles was not present in battle when Hector killed his friend, yet Achilles influenced the battle and Hector should have known that Achilles would avenge the act and kill Hector. Save


How does Achilles finally kill Hector?

There was a duel between Hector and Achilles , and Achilles was successful in killing Hector late in the day. it wasnt really a duel, it was an unfair fight, athene helped Achilles overcome hector. Achilles was also wearing god's amour and was fed on ambrosia, Achilles had refused to eat and both Odysseus and Zeus realised that a starved Achilles would be no match for a well fed hector. Achilles killed hector by thrusting his spear into his neck, the only vulnerable spot on hector's body when he was wearing Achilles' armour. both heroes exchanged spear throws, Achilles missed but athene returned his spear, hector did not miss and hit Achilles' shield, however he was tricked by athene who disguised herself as hector's brother deiphoubus holdind another spear for him and then abandoned him. hector then charges Achilles, knowing he is going to die, with his sword and he is likened to a high flying eagle, noble and strong swooping down upon Achilles who is likened to a timid hare. Achilles with athene's help slays his enemy and then proceeds to maltreat hector, this act was deemed disgusting and wrong in homeric times and still today. Zeus grows enfuriated by this as hector was his favourite mortal, aswell as Apollo's and perhaps even ares. Achilles is not the true hero of the iliad and in my view is not even a hero at all. homer intends us to feel great pathos, sympathy, for hector the greatest hero for so many more reasons than just a talented warrior. he is the most noble and brave character in Homer's Iliad.


What unforgivable act does Achilles commit at the end of The Iliad?

Achilles gets very angry at Hector for killing Patroclus his brother so he decides to get back at him. So he kills Hector, and drags his precious body around on the back of his chariot, while the whole town was watching in astonishment. Then he took him, so that he could not have his proper burial. Achilles was supposed to leave his body on the battlefield, but he was so enraged.


Should criminals be treated differently based upon justifiable homicide between murder and killing?

If the homicide was justifiable then no criminal act has been committed


How does Hector treat Helen?

Achilles and Hector fought with each other when Hector killed Achilles' friend Patroclus, and Achilles won the bet Hector asked. Hector placed a curse on Achilles, and Achilles stabbed his feet, then dragged him around town to show he won. Achilles dragged the corpse of Hector around the city walls.


Why is Achilles the protagonist and why is he flawed?

Achilles flaws are that he is driven by anger and revenge. A true hero's characteristics are goodness and honor. Achilles did not possess either and he desecrated Hector's body which is considered deplorable.


Was sethe justifiable in killing Beloved?

Sethe's act of killing Beloved can be interpreted as a desperate act of love to prevent her daughter from a life of suffering and enslavement. It was a complex and morally ambiguous decision that reflects the weight of trauma and the limitations of agency for an enslaved woman. Ultimately, whether it was justifiable is open to interpretation and depends on one's perspective.


What does achillies do with hectors body?

Achilles drags Hector's body to show off that he killed him, as an act of revenge and to make himself feel better about the death of Patroclus, but the God's restored Hector's body, which infuriated Achilles even more. He later on realizes that revenge and violence is not the answer.


What are the two different ways that Zeus distributes gifts from the two great jars of fate in book 24 of iliad?

In Book 24 of the Iliad, Zeus distributes gifts from two great jars of fate to decide the fates of Hector and Achilles. Zeus shakes the jars to select the outcome: the golden talons for Hector's favor and the black fatal destiny for Achilles. This symbolic act highlights the idea of fate and destiny as predetermined by the gods in Greek mythology.


What do you call an unintentional murder?

The term "murder" means a premeditated or preplanned killing of another person. You may be thinking of unintentional homicide, which could range from manslaughter by culpable negligence to justifiable homicide. In the case of the latter, the person must be committing a lawful act in order to claim justifiable homicide - self-defense or accident. He could still be charged with homicide by culpable negligence.


Why did south government choose to implement affirmative action policy act and was it ever justifiable?

For better employment in the country


What is tyrannicide?

the act of killing of a tyrant