According to all encyclopedias and fact sources Islam and Arabs originated 1400 years ago form Saudi Arabia and Jews originated in what is called now Israel thousands of years ago where the dispute?

Answer 1

Answer 1: Pro-Jewish Perspective

Because Mohammed and the Muslims appropriated the Jews' religion and holy places (built the dome of the rock right on top of the Hebrew temple etc.) and supplanted them as the new 'chosen people'.

Mohammed had the Jews put to death when they wouldn't convert, and proceeded tho persecute them, along with all the other 'infidels' unfortunate enough to call Muslim lands their homes, for centuries up until the present day. So the dispute kinda started at that point.

BTW all the so called Arabist 'scholars' kicking that old line about how Jews were treated Soooo Well in Muslim lands because they at least didn't wholesale genocide the Jews are all lying, despicable, racist Muslim apologists, and they know fully well how non Muslims -- Dhimma, Infidels, whatever you want to call them -- and especially Jews, whom have been demonized by Christian and Muslim civilizations for centuries, were treated in Muslim lands through out Muslim history, and it ain't no pretty picture.

Answer 2

Arabs, Turks, Magyars (Hungarians), and numerous other ethnic groups are not actually homogenous. They are composed of two historical groups that intermarried and created a unified culture. In the Arab case, Arab nomads from Arabia conquered the Levant region and brought it under their rule. During that period, those Levantines who converted to Islam began to take on the same mannerisms as the foreign Arabs who had conquered them. They began to speak the same language, dress in the same clothes, and believe in the same general ideologies. This process is well-documented by Arabs and is called Arabization or Ta3arib (تعريب). This is why the Jews and the Christians of the Upper Middle East (the Levant and Mesopotamia) often do not consider themselves Arabs. Unlike their Levantine brothers whose conversion to Islam made them more susceptible to Arabization, they retained their pre-Arabized ethnic sensibility. Therefore, although Palestinians call themselves Arabs, the majority do not and should not have lineages that go back to Arabia, but to pre-Arab ancestors in the Levant region, likely Jews, Christians, and Pagans in the Byzantine Empire.

These Palestinians, therefore were living in the land for centuries as Levantine Arabs when large numbers of Jews returned to the country from abroad. Both peoples have a historical right to the land from having had ancestors and cultural markers built by them there. As a result there have been a number of conflicts between them.