0
Yes some can when the bottom states of Texas, Oklahoma, Arkansas, and Louisiana joined the united states the created an unchangeable treaty/law to agree that they could leave at ANY time in 1861 Texas left for about a year at the end of the civil war Oklahoma has thought of leaving once in 2006 Texas ACTUALLY tried to leave but 3% to many people in Texas disagreed .
Wiki User
∙ 14y ago
The question of a state legally leaving the union is a complex and contentious issue. The U.S. Constitution does not explicitly address secession, and the Supreme Court ruled in Texas v. White (1869) that states cannot unilaterally secede. Any attempt by a state to leave the union would likely need to be resolved through a combination of constitutional amendment and negotiation.
Wiki User
∙ 16y agoApparently not. The South thought they had voluntarily joined the Union and therefore could leave it whenever they wished. The North disagreed and since the North won the war, they must have been right.
Wiki User
∙ 12y agoAfter the war between the states, the states that rejoined the Union had to swear allegiance to the Union and therefore nullifying any thought of separating from the Union. There are no legal provisions for states to leave the Union.
Aaron Burr and Alexander Hamilton had a duel over the secession of New York.
Wiki User
∙ 12y agoAnswer 1:
"Should" they be able to legally leave? Yes.
"Can" they legally leave? No.
The nation that was founded upon the right to secede does not itself acknowledge that right any more. Were a state to send in a "Declaration of Independence", as the U.S. had done to the United Kingdom, it would mean war.
Answer 2:
No they shouldn't because we are the united states of America. United means together. So no.Answer 3:
If secession isn't a right that the people have, then the U.S.A. should not have been able to leave the "United" Kingdom of Great Britain. But they did.
Answer
No, a state cannot and should not be able to legally leave the union. But, if you think about it, this makes perfect sense: If you want to leave the union, it means that you disagree with the policies of the union, so what difference does it make if its "legal" or not? Once you separate yourself, you are no longer bound by the laws which would have made it illegal to begin with.
Conversely, the Union itself would view it as an act of treason to leave them, and again, this makes perfect sense for essentially the same reason.
Wiki User
∙ 16y agoWe fought a major war over that question. The Civil War was fought over the issue of states' rights, including their ability to leave the union.
Wiki User
∙ 9y agoA state cannot leave the Union without being granted permission from the federal government. Some states have tried but it has never been done.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Can you have both a civil union and a marriage at the same time?
Yes and no: yes, if your civil union and marriage are both to the same person; no if they are to different people and both are recognized in your state. If you are in a state where your civil union is not recognized and you are married to a different person (presumably one of the opposite sex), then your civil union does not legally exist, only your marriage does.
This address is given by the president to congress?
The address given by the president to Congress is known as the State of the Union address. It is delivered annually and is used to update Congress and the American public on the current state of the nation, as well as to outline the president's legislative agenda and priorities.
What is the annual address given by the president to congress called?
The annual address given by the president to Congress is called the State of the Union address. It typically takes place in January and serves as an opportunity for the president to outline his legislative agenda and report on the state of the nation.
Did massachucestts recognize slavery as a legal institution?
Massachusetts was the only state to not recognize slavery as a legal institution. They remain the most liberal state in the union.
What are the requirements for a civil union?
Requirements for a civil union vary by location, but typically include both parties being of legal age, not being married to someone else, providing identification, and paying any necessary fees. Some jurisdictions may also require a waiting period before the civil union can take place. It's best to check with local authorities for specific requirements.
Can a state concede from the union?
Not legally. During the American Civil War, 1861 - 1865, a group of states tried to leave the Union, (secede ), and were prevented from doing so.
Was Tennessee the seventh state to leave the union?
No, Texas was the 7th to leave the Union, Tennessee was the 10th.
Is it possible for a state to leave the union?
Yes
Who was the first state to leave the union?
tennesee
What state was the first to leave from the union?
South Carolina
Why did North Carolina refuse to join the union?
North Carolina did not "refuse to join the Union." The state joined the Union in 1789, becoming the 12th state to accede to the Constitution. The state attempted to leave the Union with a secession vote in 1861 because President Lincoln called upon the state to invade South Carolina, already a member of the Confederacy. The attempt to leave the Union failed as a result of Union military victory.
Which state was the first to leave the union in December 1860?
South Carolina
What is the word that means a state trying to leave the union?
The answer to your question is "secede."
Why did the southern state leave the union when Lincoln was elected president?
South Carolina
Which state was the first to leave the union during the civil era?
South Carolina
What state was the last to leave the Union at the start of the Civil War?
South Carolina
Was Mississippi the secound state to leave the union?
Yes, Mississippi was the second to secede.
