0
Large states wanted to base representation in Congress on population. Smaller states supported the New Jersey Plan, which would have allowed each state to have an equal vote.
Wiki User
∙ 9y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
What developed between the large and small states over how representation should be chosen for the new government?
At the Constitutional Convention, states with huge populations want proportional representation. Small states wanted equal representation. The compromise consisted of the House of Representatives apportioned by population, and the Senate which has two Senators from each state.
What did small states want as far as representation in the new constitution?
They wanted equal representation for their states. Mainly because they measured how much representation you got by how many people you had in your state. So bigger cities such as New York and Pennsylvania (at the time) had alot of representation in voting and other political matters.
How did small states want to base representation in Congress?
Small states wanted representation in Congress to be equal for all states regardless of their size or population, because they felt each state was an equal partner in the new nation and feared that they would be outvoted in Congress by larger states if representation were based on population alone. The legislature would consist of two house : a House of Representatives, with membership based based on state population, and a Senate, with each state receiving two members. This agreement became known as the Connecticut Compromise.
Did Alexander Hamilton Want Equal Representation Or Proportional Representation?
Proportional. Because he came from new york, which was a large state. Obviously he didnt want the same amount as a small state like Delaware.
What did large states want as far as representation?
Large states wanted as much representation as possible for their state. They wanted this so they could have a more powerful state. They at one point planned to secede from the union. They wanted to do this so they could be even more powerful.
What did the Great Compromise want?
Main problem was the representation of large and small states. In the Great Compromise, the House of Representatives representative number would be by state population, while the Senate representative number was a fixed 2.
Why did smaller states want equal representation?
In the Virginia plan they wanted it based on population because they were a bigger state. But in the New Jersey plan they wanted an equal representation because they had a smaller population.
What did small states want at the constitutional convention?
The smaller states followed the "Connecticut Plan" which, as opposed to the larger states' preference, the "Virginia Plan," made plans for a unicameral body in which all states had equal representation - today known as the Senate. The Virginia Plan, on the other hand, was favored by the larger states because it stated that larger populations would equal greater representation in Congress - today known as the House of Representatives.
Why did the small states want equal representation?
The small states feared that the states with larger populations would control the national government. To avoid this problem, the small states wanted each state to have the same number of representatives in Congress. This is called equal representation. sources: Quigley N. Charles, Rodriguez. We the People The Citizen and the Constitution. Calabasas, CA. Center for Civic Education, 2007.
Why did some people want representation to be based on population?
With regard to representation in the House of Representatives, states are represented according to their populations. Representation in the Senate is based on 2 delegates per state, regardless of population.
Did larger states want representation from the legislature to be based on their size?
yes
What concerned larger states about their representation in congress?
Big states did not want to have only the same number of representatives as smaller states, as they had more people and a perceived need for a larger voice. Smaller states didn't want to be overpowered in the legislature by bigger, more populated states, because the small states were just as equal a part of America as were the bigger states. The Constitutional Convention elected to create both houses in the legislature - the House of Representatives, where representation is determined by population, and the Senate, where each state gets two representatives, regardless of population or size.
