Why do the Israelis and the Palestinians both want the Gaza Strip?
The Israelis believe it is rightfully theirs according to the Biblical land of Israel, but the UN-recognized border goes outside it, so the Palestinians want to have it as their own nation.
The previous opinion is incorrect. Israelis do not actually want the Gaza Strip, specifically because it is NOT part of the Biblical Land of Israel (Gaza is recognized to be part of the Philistine State in Biblical Times). The reason that there is conflict in Gaza is that Israel believes that the regime in Gaza is hard-set on the destruction of Israel. Palestinians do want the Gaza Strip, as explained by the previous opinion, so that they can have their own country.
Why is the Arab-Israeli Conflict difficult to solve?
Answer 1
The problem is that both sides have legitimacy in certain claims and extremists who would rather derail the process of negotiations than not get everything in their wishlists. The Israelis and the Palestinians who truly want to live together in peace respecting each others' Rights to Exist have had to consistently those who would rather stir up antagonism and hatred on both sides.
Arab Answer
Simply, because of the Arab lands occupied by the Israelis. The Arabs, through the Arab League made the initiative that Israelis withdraw from the Arab lands occupied in war 1967 and all the Arab States start political, economic and diplomatic relations with Israel. However, the Israelis ignored the initiative completely.
Israeli Answer
The above answer is disingenuous about what the Arab League Initiative represents and while it does say that all Arab nations will have peaceful and diplomatic relations with the State of Israel at its conclusion, the Initiative does not provide for major Israeli concerns. The foremost of these concerns is that not every Palestinian can live in the Jewish State of Israel. Doing this would remove its Jewish Character and make Israel a de facto Arab State. This is a non-starter. The Arabs are to be commended for making a great compromise, but they refused to negotiate any terms in the Saudi Peace Initiative and made it a "take it or leave it" deal. This inability of the Arabs to seriously mind Israeli concerns and be open to a full negotiation is the reason why the Initiative failed, not an unwillingness of the Israelis to accept peace.
However, the Arabs are not the only ones furthering the conflict. The Israeli government currently is belligerent and encourages settlements in East Jerusalem and the West Bank, hampering the peace process. On the flip side, Gaza is run by the Militant Terrorist Organization Hamas which constantly attacks Israel and is not interested in fruitful negotiations. Both sides are at fault for the current rounds of fighting, but the bottom line is that at the end of the day, most Israelis and Palestinians in the former British Mandate of Palestine realize that a Two-State Solution is the only one that is viable. It is Jews and Arabs outside of this area who still demand total victory for their side.
Answer 3
Religion. Jews and Muslims don't like each other.
Answer 4
Many years ago the region of Palestine had Jews, Christians, and Muslims with relatively minimal violence.
Lots of Jews in other countries were being pushed out because people were jealous of their wealth or just wanted their farms, so certain politicians and rulers who believed that the bible was true decided to allow some of the Jews to live in Palestine.
Those who arrived in Palestine decided that, as this was their home, more Jews should live there.
In 1948 the politicians in other countries agreed to split Palestine into separate areas for Jews and Palestinians, this started a war between the Palestinians and the Jews which the Jews won.
Ever since that time the Jews, (Israelis), have been pushing out the Palestinians, (mostly Muslims), from their land and the other Muslim states have been helping the Palestinians.
Additional Information
There are many additional reasons. Please see the Related Question to read about the Causes of the Arab-Israeli Conflict, many of which have not yet been resolved.
Is Palestine a country or city?
The Palestinian Authority, which de jure governs parts of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip (de facto it does not govern the Gaza Strip) has non-member status in the UN, has difficulty collecting taxes, and cannot raise a sanctioned defense force. On the flip side, it maintains police and fire departments, sets taxes, builds and maintains schools and roads, engages in international diplomacy, and exports its people's products abroad.
Thus the PA is a quasi-nation.
Who did the Palestinian terrorists take hostage during the Munich Massacre in 1972?
11 Israeli athletes
What impact did the formation of Israel have upon the Arab people of that land?
On the one hand, many Arab people were displaced, whether deliberately by the Jewish fighters and settlers, or by the Arabs' own decision. Many felt disenfranchised.
On the other hand, the living standard of Arabs in Israel is significntly higher than in Arab and Muslim countries. Israel has brought employment and modern conveniences to the entire population. Those who have chosen to be Israeli citizens have many towns and villages, and own very many businesses throughout the country. Here in the Galilee region, Arabs and Jews live in close proximity and generally get along well.
They were established by Israel as a counterbalance to the PLO.
Meanwhile, back on Earth . . .
Based on the principles of Islamic fundamentalism gaining momentum throughout
the Arab world in the 1980s, Hamas was founded in 1987 (during the First Intifada)
as an offshoot of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood. Co-founder Sheik Ahmed Yassin
stated in 1987 and the Hamas Charter affirmed in 1988 that Hamas was founded to
liberate Palestine from Israeli occupation and to establish an Islamic state in the area
that is now Israel, the West Bank, and the Gaza Strip.
Why was palestine divided into two countries?
In 1947 the united nations voted to divide Palestine into a Jewish and a Arab state. while arab counries rejected this plan, the Jews accepted it, and a year later created the state of Israel.
Who is right Israel or Palestine?
Israel is Israel and Palestine is Palestine. Confusion occurs because both things refer to an extant piece of land with people living on it, a nationality, an ethnicity, and a prior piece of land which no longer exists.
Israel is a Jewish State that contains territory from the former British Mandate of Palestine. The remainder of the British Mandate of Palestine belongs to the modern Palestinian State. Israel is a majority Jewish population who returned from their Exile in Europe and the Middle East. Palestinians are a majority Arab population whose families lived in the region for centuries. Palestinians did not simply become Israelis (except for those who did not flee during the Israeli-Arab War of 1948-9) or vice versa.
If the question is asking why Israel exists where Palestine formerly existed, the premise is faulty. Palestine was the name that the British assigned to that piece of land regardless of its history. Prior to the British, the Ottomans administered Palestine as three distinct regions: Vilayet of Beirut (which included Lebanon and northern Israel), the Vilayet of Damascus (which included Syria, Jordan, and southern Israel), and the Mutasaffirat of Jerusalem (which included central Israel and the Palestinian Territories). The name had nothing to do with the previous administration or the indigenous peoples.
As a result, when the Palestinian Jews declared independence, they chose to call their country according to how they see themselves. This is no different than how the British colony of Rhodesia in Africa became independent as Zambia in the north and Zimbabwe in the south. Since the British name was unconnected to the people on that land, the people reasserted their own identity. Since the Palestinian Arabs did not have a unique identity prior to Israeli independence, they continued to use the term Palestinian to describe their experience.
Where are the West Bank and the Gaza Strip located?
The West Bank is a kidney-bean shaped piece of land on the West Bank of the Jordan River, bordered on its east both by the river and by the Kingdom of Jordan. It is bordered on the north, south, and west by State of Israel. The West Bank also controls a quarter of the Dead Sea.
The Gaza Strip is a thin coastal piece of land, bordered on the northwest by the Mediterranean Sea. It is bordered on the northeast and southeast by the State of Israel. It is bordered in the southwest by the Republic of Egypt.
When did Palestine become the nation of Israel officially?
Israel declared their independence from the British in 1948. Then was attacked by six other countries within an hour who refused to accept it as a nation. There was never peace because they claimed Israel was not a nation so a ceasefire was called instead. Please people stop editing things just for fun this is a resource not an online game. most people dont appreciate it!
What is the time period of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict?
The conflicts that involved both the State of Israel and an Arab belligerent force occurred during the following years, 1948-49, 1956, 1967-70, 1973, 1981-82, 1987-1993, 1995-2000, 2006, and 2008-09. These correspond to the Arab-Israeli War of 1948-9, the Suez Crisis, the Six-Day War and the War of Attrition, the Arab-Israeli War of 1973, the Israeli involvement in the Lebanese Civil War, the First Intifada, the Second Intifada, the War with Hezbollah, and Operation Cast Lead.
Religious Festivals of First Century Palestine?
The religion in the first century was the Jewish religion
What religions are in conflict in Palestine?
It depends what you mean by "Palestine".
If you are referring exclusively to the Palestinian Territories, there are abuses by Muslim Palestinians of Christian Palestinians and the defacing of their holy sites and monuments. Additionally, there is a conflict between Jewish Israeli Settlers and Israeli Soldiers and Palestinians (both Muslim and Christian).
If you are using "Palestine" as a shorthand for "Israel and Palestine", then the religions in the conflict are Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. However, those religions are not at conflict. The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict is a ethnic/nationalist conflict where religions are used as ethnic identifiers (similar to the 1990s in Yugoslavia). It is not a theological conflict.
Why did Palestinians flee what is now known as Israel?
Answer 1
"Invaders arrived with guns and forced them out."
Answer 2
Answer 1 is a rhetorical answer to this rhetorical question, when in fact a more accurate statement might be: Arabs that remained in Israel and whom chose to live peacefully became what is known as Israeli Arabs, and Arabs that either participated in pogroms or sided with Arab nations who sought Israel's destruction Identified themselves as "Palestinian".
Arabs prior to the six day war in 1967, were given aid from Arab nations and were informed that if they remained after the loss of the Jordanian controlled (woe to Jordan if they were to establish a homeland for the Palestinians when they had a chance) West bank, they would lose this aid and Arab propaganda told them they would have no safe haven.
Additionally, many Native Palestinian Arabs residing in Jordan (also part of the original Palestinian mandate) were not recognized by the ruling family in Jordan favored by the Brittish for fighting the Turks during WWI, rose up against the Jordanians and were massacred on a very large scale by the Jordanians. (For more information read about the founding of the PLO and Black September.) Today, of course The King of Jordan styles himself as a Champion of Palestinian Rights and argues for the "Right of Return" as he would be happy to rid his own country of any Malcontents.
Arab Nations continue to exploit the Arabs that remained in Israel as a method of creating political and security problems as they were unable to destroy Israel in conventional wars.
Surely, Palestinian Arabs are the odd men out in middle eastern Politics as are the Kurds, Turkmen, Assyrians, and the Copts (who live under Arab rule with no homeland). But placing the blame exclusively on the founding of Israel is unbalanced.
What year did the United Nations decide to split palestine?
In 1947, the United States and the Soviet Union agreed that Palestine (Israel) should be divided. In November 1947, a UN Special Committee on Palestine presented a report to the General Assembly, with a majority advocating division, but a minority advocating a unitary state based on democracy. Of course, this did not yet divide the territory, but it set the process in train. At first, the proposal was for the Palestinians to receive the major portion of the divided territory, but the Jews gradually achieved concessions, until a United Nations "Green Line" was drawn, dividing the territory approximately into two, by means of four sectors which touched at one point, so that a Jew or Palestinian need not cross the other's territory in order to move from one of his two sectors to the other. After the British forces moved out in 1948, the Jews declared independence, thus pre-empting any formal action by the UN to split the territory. 1948
Where is Israel under Palestine's control?
Yes, Palestine was a country. When Israel was created in 1948, the land was occupied by the British and before that the Turkish Empire. When the UN created Israel after the Holocaust they wanted to split the land in half. Half as Palestine and half as Israel. Arabs did not like the idea. As the British retreated from Israel all the neighboring Arab countries tried to take over Israel. A war ensued and as the Jewish people pushed back their Arab neighbors they declared the land Israel. Palestinians today who live in the West Bank were Jordanian before the war, but never went back to live Jordan, because they want to stay in their home country. The West Bank and Gaza both are Palestinian and are still in Israel, but are run by their own Palestinian governments. Palestinians are determined to get THEIR land back.
___________________________________________________________ Palestine has been semi-autonomous (the Palestinian Authority) since renouncing war on Israel in the 1990's. As stated above, the Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza now govern themselves, but they are not an independent country. They are still technically part of Israel. A study of history will show that this land has had many rulers before the Israelis, the Brits, and the Turks. But as the Arabs say"our land will be back".
How were the Palestinians induced to give up their land?
The Palestinians didn't lose their country. Actually, not all of them. Most of the Palestinians still live in what was called the British Mandate of Palestine. Most of them in the West Bank and the Gaza strip and in Israel still remains a large Arab community. The Arabs in Israel are called Israeli Arabs and make up about 20 % of the Israeli population and got equal rights. They are the only Arabs in the Middle East who are allowed to vote! The first homeland for the Arab/Palestinians was Transjordan, which was cut off from the British Mandate of Palestine in 1922. The remaining part would be available for a Jewish National Home. When the UN in 1947 wanted to share the rest of Palestine 50/50 into a Jewish State and another Arab State the Arabs rejected the partition and the Jews accepted it. The Arab/Palestinian spiritual leader called: 'Kill the Jews, my Muslim brothers!' 'Drive them into the sea'. After the British withdraw from Palestine, David Ben Gurion declared the Independence and rebirth of the Jewish State of Israel in 1948. Israel was the first independent Jewish State in the Jewish home region after 19 centuries of foreign rule and diaspora. Short after the Israeli Independence Declaration all the Arab countries attacked Israel. In the Israeli-Arab war (in Israel called the War of Independence) some more then 500 thousands of Arabs/Palestinians who lived between 1946-1948 in Palestine fled away. Most of them fled to the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, which was part of historical British Palestine. These people actually didn't leave what they call their Palestine! Those territories remained to become a Palestinian State. However Transjordan and Egypt who occupied it didn't give it to the Palestinians! There only goal was to destroy Israel, they didn't care about the 'Palestinians'. However a smaller group fled to Southern Lebanon and Syria. The Arabs locked them up into refugee camps so the people would grow and grow because of the poverty and the lack of hygienical care (condoms!). They used and use them as a demographic weapon against Israel. At the same time from 1948 to the 70s more then 1 million Jews fled from the Arab world to Israel from Persia, Yemen, Iraq, Egypt, Tunesia etc. (See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_exodus_from_Arab_and_Muslim_countries) These people would have had no future in islamitic countries where Jews never have had equal rights. All the governments of the State of Israel from the Independence till now have announced as long as the Arabs don't recognize the right of the State of Israel to exist the Arabs should resolve their 'Palestinian' issue on their own ground (there are more then 15 MILLION square kilometers left, comparing to Israel which is only 22 thousand square kilometers).
The UN thought most of the fled Arab Palestinians would also be happy to live in the West Bank under Jordanian Rule and the Gaza Strip and Egyptian Rule , the rule of their Arab brothers. This was true until in the 60s the PLO came to exist, to destroy Israel. Short there after in 1967 (the 6 Day War) Israel occupied the West Bank and the Gaza Strip. They never drove the Palestinians living there away. There were refugees in 1967, but all of them returned. In the 90s the territories inhabited by Palestinians on the West Bank (most of the West Bank) got their own administration in the Palestinian National Authority. This is called the Israeli-Palestinian interim agreement. In 2005 Israel withdraw from the Gazastrip. The permanent status of these territories has to be achieved by negotiations between the Palestinian Authority and Israel which can lead to the creation of the first independent Palestinian State (if you don't count Jordan which is actually also a Palestinian State!) in the whole history next to the State of Israel. Obstacles are the Israeli settlements and the Arabs who don't want to recognize the right of existence of the State of Israel.
You can say most of the Palestinians didn't lose there country. In Israel the remaining Palestinian Arabs have got equal rights as Jews, aswell as in the Palestinian territories they administrate themself, aswell as in Jordan most of the Palestinian refugees nowadays are Jordanian citizens. The West of Jordan is also included in historical Palestine at the time of the Arab Empire when most of the nowadays called Palestinian Arabs immigrated to Palestine from the Arab Peninsula. According to that theory, all the Palestinians still live in historical Palestine.
*The only way to peace is when both parties understand each others stories and rights to live in the conflict territory!
What is the root cause of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict?
Easy answer for a difficult problem: 1. They (Europeans, inc Britain) made a nation out of someone else's country 2. See the link below for more information.
The Ottoman Empire owned most of the Middle East since the 16th century. It became an ally of Germany's during WWI. the British offered to give the Arabs independence in return for their help in defeating Germany and the Ottoman Empire. The Arabs agreed and, led by Lawrence of Arabia, fought in the war on the side of Britain.
After WWI, however, the British reneged. Britain and France entered into a secret pact, called the Sykes-Picot Treaty, to divide up the former Ottoman Empire after the war. ( See The Balfour Declaration,
Then, after WWII, a homeland for the Jews (Israel) was established in Palestine, and a flood of Europeans, who had never set foot in the Middle East, arrived and took away land that had belonged to the Arabs for millenia.
These refuges relocated to the half of Palestine that was left to them after the creation of Israel. From the Arab point of view, they have been lied to, cheated, and run off their land. They are very resentful of the Jews, whom they see as Europeans, who were given Their land. Also, they are just plain Angry at having their loyalty betrayed.
From the Israeli point of view, Israel is only Part of Their land, which they fled after Rome destroyed Solomon's temple in 70 a.d. The land belongs to them, pure and simple.
There are some Israelis who believe that All of ancient Israel should be returned to them, and are building settlements in an effort to retake the Rest of their land, which is currently occupied by Palestinians, since it is in the half given to them in the partition.
For additional information on the Causes of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, please see the Related Question below.
Why are the Occupied Palestinian Territories a source of conflict?
Pro-Palestinian Answer
Israel stole the land via safety zones or forced those out of work and bought the land for a pittance. Israel continues to occupy the stolen land and defies all peace talks.
Only recently Israel murdered an opposition leader while peace talks where being negotiated in Russia. Israel has no interest in peace or dividing the land equally.
Answer
The Occupied Palestinian Territories are a source of conflict because Israel has control of the territory, but is not well represented by the civilian population of the region. Palestinians have a claim to that piece of land and Israel has actively prevented the realization of that claim through the use of settlements. Palestinians have actively prevented the realization of their own claim by circumventing the peace process and, in the case of Hamas, actively seeking to torpedo peace talks and launching rockets at civilian areas with the intent to sow the seeds of conflict.
To see general causes of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, please see the Related Question below.
How can Palestinians claim their homeland as Palestine?
Arabs, Turks, Magyars (Hungarians), and numerous other ethnic groups are not actually homogenous. They are composed of two historical groups that intermarried and created a unified culture. In the Arab case, Arab nomads from Arabia conquered the Levant region and brought it under their rule. During that period, those Levantines who converted to Islam began to take on the same mannerisms as the foreign Arabs who had conquered them. They began to speak the same language, dress in the same clothes, and believe in the same general ideologies. This process is well-documented by Arabs and is called Arabization or Ta3arib (تعريب). This is why the Jews and the Christians of the Upper Middle East (the Levant and Mesopotamia) often do not consider themselves Arabs. Unlike their Levantine brothers whose conversion to Islam made them more susceptible to Arabization, they retained their pre-Arabized ethnic sensibility. Therefore, although Palestinians call themselves Arabs, the majority do not and should not have lineages that go back to Arabia, but to pre-Arab ancestors in the Levant region, likely Jews, Christians, and Pagans in the Byzantine Empire.
(The Turks "Turk-ified" the formerly Byzantine population of central Anatolia and most of modern Turkey and had some effect elsewhere in the Balkans. The Magyars made the sedentary population of the Hungarian Empire into Hungarians through conversion to the Catholic Church and the proliferation of the Hungarian Language and customs.)
What is the name of the land Israel and Palestine are fighting for?
Palestinians (Philistines in the Bible) lived in Palestine. Then many Jewish people came and took the farms, cities, and land, and called it Israel. The Palestinians want the invaders to go away. The Israelis want to stay and to expand their small country.
What two pieces of land occupied by Israel may eventually become a Palestine homeland?
This question seems to be fishing for "the Gaza Strip and West Bank". However,
neither of these territories is "in" Israel, and Israel is not fighting to acquire either
of them. The Gaza Strip is completely administrated by Hamas, and the West Bank
is under partial Israeli Military Occupation, but is a foreign territory.
===================================
Another contributor added:
The only "piece of land" that one could accurately describe as "being fought over in
Israel" is Israel itself. The government and general population of Israel are determined
that their nation shall survive as a sovereign and autonomous entity, while a large group
of other nations, both neighboring and worldwide, are equally determined, to the point of
periiodic military and terrorist action, that it shall not.
Who gave Jews the land of Palestine?
Palestina allowed them to live there and later on it became ‘Israel’ and now they kill Palestinian children and nobody talks about it but if any act of terrorism happens by any muslim the whole world reacts
It depends on where this "Palestinian State" would be.
However, assuming that the "Palestinian State" refers to a Palestinian State made according to the 1967 borders with acceptable landswaps, the benefits to Israelis and Palestinians become rather simple. The benefit that accrues to Israelis is that Israel can remain a Jewish-majority state and therefore fulfill the mission for which it was created: to be a Jewish and Democratic State. The benefit that accrues to the Palestinians is that they finally have a state in which to determine their own future as opposed to the way that Israel and the other Arab States have treated them.
The disadvantages are rather different. In the case of Israel, Israelis fear that an independent Palestinian State will allow for the development of terrorist Anti-Zionist groups that will target Israeli civilians. Israeli Settlers will most likely be ordered to leave the Palestinian State and those areas will become essentially Judenrein. Finally, Jews will likely lose access to the innumerable Jewish Holy Sites in the West Bank (such as Joseph's Tomb in Nablus, the Cave of the Patriarchs in Hebron, the Tomb of Rachel, etc.) In the case of Palestine, Palestinians will lose the complete Right of Return and will have to accept that some of them will never be able to live in the house that their grandparents or great-grandparents lived in. Palestine most likely will be a demilitarized region, which means that Palestinians would require faith in their allies and protectors to maintain a proper defense.
Goals of Hamas
The following are the goals of Hamas as described in the Charter of Hamas, a link to which has been provided below. Each bulletpoint references the Article of the Charter where these views are discussed:
Description of Hamas
Hamas is a Palestinian Sunni Islamic or Islamist political party that governs the Gaza Strip and the largest and most influential Palestinian militant movement along with the more moderate Fatah party and has a military wing called the Izz ad-Din al-Qassam Brigades. Hamas is viewed by most Western analysts as an obstacle to the Arab-Israeli peace process and the goal of a two-state solution. As a result, Western nations, including the United States, have tried to embolden the Fatah-led Palestinian Authority while isolating Hamas, which has historically kept strong ties to Iran.
Hamas was founded by Sheikh Ahmed Yassin, a Palestinian spiritual leader who became an activist in the local branch of the Muslim Brotherhood after dedicating his early life to Islamic scholarship in Cairo. Beginning in the late 1960s, Yassin preached and performed charitable work in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, both of which were seized by Israeli forces following the 1967 Six-Day War. In 1973, he established al-Mujamma' al-Islami (the Islamic Center) to coordinate the Brotherhood's political activities in Gaza.
Hamas' primary base of popular support is in the Gaza Strip, where it has maintained de facto control since its 2006, when it surprised many observers by winning the majority of seats in the Palestinian parliament. Hamas ousted the remnants of Fatah from Gaza by force in early 2007, and the new Hamas-led government was summarily dismissed by PA president and Fatah chief Mahmoud Abbas. The result of the bloodshed was a de facto geographic division of Palestinian-held territory, with Hamas holding sway in Gaza and Fatah maintaining the internationally recognized Palestinian Authority government in the West Bank town of Ramallah.
Hamas' control over the area was established after the Hamas party won the Palestinian legislative elections in January 2006,[4] and ousted Fatah officials during the Battle of Gaza in 2007.[5] Fatah, Hamas' political and military rival, controls the West Bank.[6] Both regimes - the Palestinian National Authority and the Hamas administration - regard themselves as the sole legitimate Palestinian government.