answersLogoWhite

0

Anti-Semitism

Anti-Semitism is prejudice towards, hatred of, or discrimination against Jews as a national, ethnic, religious or racial group. The term was coined in Germany in 1860 as a scientific-sounding term for Judenhass ("Jew-hatred") and does not refer to Non-Jewish Semites. Anti-Semitism takes many forms, ranging from hateful words uttered to individual Jews to organized violent attacks by mobs, state police, or even military attacks on entire Jewish communities.

462 Questions

Was Mackenzie King antisemitic?

Mackenzie King, the former Prime Minister of Canada, exhibited attitudes and behaviors that many historians and scholars interpret as antisemitic. He expressed negative views about Jewish people in his private diaries and was known to have held beliefs that reflected the antisemitism prevalent in his time. His government also implemented restrictive immigration policies that disproportionately affected Jewish refugees during the Holocaust. While some argue that his actions were more reflective of the era's prejudices than personal hatred, the evidence suggests a significant degree of bias.

What do critics say about anti-semitism in Oliver Twist?

Critics often highlight the portrayal of the character Fagin in Charles Dickens' "Oliver Twist" as a significant example of anti-Semitism. Fagin is depicted with stereotypical traits associated with Jewish people, such as greed and cunning, which has led to accusations that Dickens perpetuates negative stereotypes. While some argue that Dickens' intention was to critique societal attitudes towards Jews, many believe that the character ultimately reinforces harmful prejudices. This portrayal has sparked extensive debate about the intersection of literature and social values in the 19th century.

Did Harbor Springs have an anti-semitic residential area in the 1900s?

Yes, Harbor Springs, like many other communities in the early 1900s, had elements of anti-Semitism that were reflected in real estate practices. Discriminatory covenants and social norms often restricted Jewish residents from purchasing homes in certain areas. This was part of a broader pattern of exclusionary practices prevalent in various parts of the United States during that time.

How was life like for the Jews that didn't go to the camps?

For Jews who did not go to the camps during the Holocaust, life was marked by fear, uncertainty, and constant danger. Many faced severe restrictions, including loss of employment, forced relocation to ghettos, and social ostracism. They lived in hiding or under false identities, often relying on the bravery of non-Jews for shelter and support. The threat of deportation loomed constantly, creating a pervasive atmosphere of anxiety and despair.

Is Shakespeare' characterisation of shylock antisemitic?

Shakespeare's characterization of Shylock in "The Merchant of Venice" can be seen as reflecting the antisemitic attitudes of his time, portraying him as both a complex and villainous figure. While Shylock exhibits depth and humanity, particularly through his famous speech on suffering and shared humanity, he is also depicted with negative stereotypes associated with Jewish people. This duality complicates the interpretation, as some argue that Shakespeare critiques societal prejudices, while others contend that his portrayal reinforces harmful stereotypes. Ultimately, the character can be viewed as a product of Elizabethan views on Jews, making the question of antisemitism multifaceted.

Why did the Arabs do a pogrom in Africa in 1945?

The term "pogrom" typically refers to a violent riot aimed at the massacre or persecution of a particular ethnic or religious group. In 1945, anti-Jewish violence in North Africa, particularly in cities like Cairo and Tripoli, was fueled by rising nationalist sentiments, the impact of World War II, and growing resentment against foreign influences. These events were exacerbated by the perception of Jews as associated with Western colonial powers. The violence was part of a broader context of social and political upheaval in the region during this period.

What age did germans make jews work?

During the Nazi regime in Germany, Jews were subjected to forced labor starting in the late 1930s and escalating during World War II. Many Jewish men, women, and even children were compelled to work in various industries, including munitions and agriculture. The age at which Jews were forced to work varied, but it often included individuals as young as 14 or 15. This exploitation was part of the broader system of persecution and dehumanization that characterized the Holocaust.

What was the date that Most scholars conclude that Arab anti-Semitism in the modern world arose in the?

Most scholars conclude that Arab anti-Semitism in the modern world arose in the late 19th to early 20th century, particularly around the time of World War I and the subsequent establishment of the British Mandate in Palestine. This period saw the rise of nationalist movements and increased tensions between Arab and Jewish communities, influenced by European anti-Semitic ideologies. The conflict over land and political rights further exacerbated these sentiments, leading to a more pronounced and systemic form of anti-Semitism in the Arab world.

What is the basis for antisemitism throughout history?

Antisemitism has historically stemmed from a combination of religious, economic, and social factors. Religious animosity, particularly within Christian contexts, often portrayed Jews as Christ-killers, leading to widespread persecution. Additionally, Jews were sometimes scapegoated during economic crises, accused of greed or manipulation, which fueled resentment. Over time, these prejudices were compounded by conspiracy theories and nationalist sentiments, solidifying antisemitism as a persistent and dangerous ideology.

What kind of human needs did anti-semitism seem to satisfy?

Anti-Semitism often satisfied various psychological and social needs, including the desire for a scapegoat during times of economic or social turmoil. It provided a sense of belonging to a group that could unify against a perceived common enemy, fostering in-group identity. Additionally, it allowed individuals to project their fears and frustrations onto a marginalized community, thus deflecting attention from their own challenges. Ultimately, anti-Semitism served to reinforce social hierarchies and justify discriminatory beliefs and actions.

Why were Jews the most hated people during the Great Depression?

During the Great Depression, Jews were often scapegoated for the economic hardships faced by many, as they were falsely blamed for the financial crisis and associated societal problems. Pre-existing anti-Semitic stereotypes and prejudices were exacerbated by the economic turmoil, leading to increased discrimination and violence against Jewish communities. Additionally, extremist political movements, particularly in Europe, exploited these sentiments to gain support by promoting conspiracy theories that depicted Jews as responsible for society's ills. This scapegoating ultimately contributed to a climate of intolerance and hatred against Jews during this tumultuous period.

Why did Russia hate the Jews?

Russia's historical animosity towards Jews stemmed from a combination of religious, social, and economic factors. Jews were often scapegoated for societal problems, facing discrimination and violence, particularly during the Tsarist regime. Anti-Semitic stereotypes portrayed Jews as outsiders and threats to Russian identity, exacerbated by economic competition and their roles in urban professions. These tensions culminated in violent pogroms and the promotion of repressive policies, particularly in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

What Anti Semitism was at Council of Nicea?

At the Council of Nicaea in 325 CE, anti-Semitism was primarily reflected in the tensions between early Christians and Jewish communities. The Council sought to define Christian doctrine and address issues such as the date of Easter, which highlighted the growing rift between Christians and Jews. Some early Christian leaders viewed Jewish practices and beliefs as a threat, leading to the marginalization of Jewish influence in the developing Christian faith and the promotion of negative stereotypes about Jews. This laid groundwork for future theological and social animosities between the two groups.

Was the theologian Calvin antisemitic?

John Calvin, the 16th-century theologian, expressed views that can be interpreted as antisemitic, particularly in his writings where he criticized Jewish beliefs and practices. He believed in the theological superiority of Christianity over Judaism and described Jews in ways that reflected the prejudices of his time. However, it is important to contextualize his views within the broader historical framework of the Reformation and the prevailing attitudes toward Jews in Europe during that period. While some of his writings contain negative portrayals of Jews, the extent and nature of his antisemitism are subjects of ongoing scholarly debate.

Was Bing Crosby anti-semitic?

I'm no Bing Crosby expert, but I've never read anything that would lead me to believe he was racist. Especially in context of the day and age in which he lived, when views on many issues were quite different than they are now.

I assume you raise the question because he performed in blackface on a few occasions. There is a clip of one instance here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tAHSTbD4A5M along with some interesting commentary below.

Some assert that Bing, like Frank Sinatra, stood up for his fellow musicians who were black. Others discuss the history the of minstrel show and blackface tradition, which they claim was actually, in some ways, a positive force for race relations. That is hard to grasp for most of us today, but I found the discussion interesting as I knew little of the tradition, which was gone by the time I was born.

In any case, Bing would probably be pleasantly surprised to learn we have an African-American president. America is supposed to be about progress, and doubtless by the time you and I are very old and gray, many things will have come to pass which we would not have dreamed.
---


Bing Crosby was definitely not a racist. He produced albums with Ella Fitzgerald ("Christmas Jump & Live" to name just one of them).


The big band/swing artists of that era seemed to not care about race as much as their parent's generation. Take the Rat Pack for example. Sinatra and Dean Martin would not be the rack pack without Sammy Davis, Jr., a black man.


Besides, Bing Crosby was a jazz singer. Jazz is a black tradition. He's in black territory--so he better not be racist. It'd be like a white racist from Georgia wanting to live in Harlem. Doesn't happen. Crosby was not a racist. (Neither of the two men with that name were racists.)

What provokes anti-semitism?

Answer 1

This is an important question. Why is there so much antisemitism (hatred or prejudice against Jewish people) in the world now, and why has there been in the past?

Here are some opinions from various contributors

1. We don't know.

2. They have set themselves apart. Jews have been remarkably good at maintaining communities within communities. They have maintained their ethnic and religious identity over many generations instead of becoming part of the cultures in which they live. Groups that set themselves apart always attract prejudice. For example, Italian and Irish immigrants were hated for various reasons by many native-born Americans in the 19th century. As they assimilated into the mainstream American culture they did not face the same prejudice (if for no other reason, just because they can't easily be identified as different). Minority groups that do not or cannot assimilate tend to attract prejudice.

3. They have been very successful. Their cultural values encourage education and material success, and so many of them become wealthy and powerful. This naturally attracts the envy of people who are less successful. Instead of respecting other people for their success, many of us find it easier to think that they had some unfair advantage, or there is a conspiracy, etc. (However, at various times and in various places, such as Eastern Europe in the period c.1800-1945 they were despised because of their poverty!)

4. Not everyone hates Jews, although they certainly have their problems with others in this world. I have Jewish friends and have worked for several Jewish bosses, and they were absolutely wonderful to me. You don't have to believe in another's religion (I'm Protestant) but I always love to see some of the ceremonies of different religions if I am invited and consider it an honor.

5. For a long time the Jews were excluded.

It says above, "They have set themselves apart". This needs comment. In Europe, where antisemitism started, the Jews were for several centuries excluded from ordinary society, shunned and in many countries they were forced to live in small, designated areas of towns called ghettos. They were also banned from most occupations. Of particular significance until a little after 1800 was the fact that they were banned from agriculture, which was by far the most important sector of the economy before the rise of industry. Moreover, they weren't just excluded from mainstream society, they were demonized. All kinds of absurd conspiracy theories were invented about the Jews. They were set apart.

6. Conflict in the Middle East

More recently, conflict between Israel and other countries in the Middle East has led to the rise of anti-Jewish feeling in that region and further afield.

7. Misunderstanding, prejudice and jealousy

The same reasons why some people hate other nationalities, other sex orientations, other religions, etc, etc.

8. Antisemitism is self-perpetuating

It has become a kind of tradition. In particular, conspiracy theories about Jews are often seen as interesting and spicy (even if they are not believed), while conspiracy theories about most other groups are just seen as downright boring and get very little attention.

Answer 2

Joy Hakim, the author of the History of US, suggests some possible beginnings of anti-Semitism, which are:

  1. Jews held onto their culture and refused to convert to Christianity
  2. Some Christians that believed that anyone that was not Christian (infidels) should be converted or die
  3. Many Jews had a high economic status, and many people became jealous of their success
  4. The Theory of Evolution was used against Jews (by Hitler and the Nazis) to attempt to prove that Jews were inferior to the Aryan race.

Comment

Answer 2 merrily mixes possible reasons from a wide range of periods. As for 'high economic status', often in many places Jews were despised for their poverty - for example, in Tsarist Russia.

Who wrote Racism Antisemitism and Psychoanalysis?

The book "Racism, Antisemitism, and Psychoanalysis" was written by Earl Hopper. It explores the intersection of these topics and how psychoanalytic theory can shed light on racist and antisemitic attitudes and behaviors.

How is antisemitism internalized?

The unquestioned use of stereoypes and the unthinking acceptance of fanciful conspiracy theories play a key role in such processes of 'internalization'; also, then only seeing or noticing things that seem to fit the stereotype and the fashionable conspiracy theories. Or, to put it simply, never exploring but just seeing what one wants to see.

What can you do to stop Anti Semitism?

There is no simple formula. I think it can only be done within the framework of a broad campaign against racism. Key elements include getting to know more about the people ... For example, many anti-Semites know nothing about actual Jews, only the stereoypes and caricatures - and malicious stuff on the internet.

Why do Non-Jews sometimes feel threatened by Jews?

Among non-Jews, it is essentially Christians who have a history of persecuting Jews. Edward Gibbon (The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire) says that in spite of repeated insurrection by the Jews, the pagan rulers were very tolerant towards their beliefs. The New Testament tells Christians that the Jews opposed the teachings of Jesus and were responsible for his death, and arguably incites anti-Jewish sentiment.

What does the term anti-Semitism mean and when was the term first used?

The word antisemitic is slightly older and the first reference dates from 1865. The word antisemitism dates from 1879. The antisemitic word means anti-Jewish. The term antisemitism was first used by Wilhelm Marr for his anti-Jewish political movement. He was fed up with being called a Jew-baiter (Judenhetzer) and wanted to show the world that he, too, had an ideology or -ism to solve the world's problems.

Was Roald Dahl antisemitic?

Most likely not. Rudyard Kipling used a swastika on the first editions of his books, but this was before the Nazi party adopted the swastika. He used the swastika because it was the symbol of good luck. Before the Nazi party came to power he had the engraver remove it from the printing block. He did not want it to seem like he was supporting them. Hence he was probably not antisemitic or a Nazi sympathizer.

Was Charles Dickens anti-semitic?

There is no indication that Charles Dickens ever was anti-semitic. Some have argued that he was, based on the fact that he had made Fagin, the villain of Oliver Twist, a Jew. Dickens had however based Fagin on a real person who had been convicted - in real life - for doing the exact same things (recruiting and training children for pickpocketing and other petty crimes) as Fagin: the - Jewish - criminal Ikey Solomon.

Charles Dickens is on record as stating: "I have no feeling towards the Jews but a friendly one. I always speak well of them, whether in public or private, and bear my testimony (as I ought to do) to their perfect good faith in such transactions as I have ever had with them" and he later removed almost all mentions of Fagin's Jewishness from the text of Oliver Twist when he found that these gave offence to his Jewish friends and acquaintances.

Why was Roald Dahl anti-semitic?

There was some controversy over this because he had made some anti-sementic remarks over the Isareli invasion of Lebennon. However, he went back and corrected what he said and apoloized for the remarks and said that it was taken the wrong way.


Roald Dahl told a reporter in 1983, "There's a trait in the Jewish character that does provoke animosity ... I mean there is always a reason why anti-anything crops up anywhere; even a stinker like Hitler didn't just pick on them for no reason." He never apologized for this horrible racist remark. It is hard to see how it could be taken "the wrong way".